Many have wondered over the years – Are the three Keady families who first emigrated to Victoria in the 1800s related ?
Quick Summary
- John Keady (1812-1884) and Honora Kenny (1811-1892) arrived in Melbourne in 1841 with four children.
- Two brothers, Thomas Keady (1834-1907) and Patrick Nolan Keady(1830-1913) arrived in the mid 1850s. Thomas in 1854 and Patrick in 1855.
- Daniel Keady(1838-1928) arrived in Melbourne about 1858 according to his son. (No official records can be found of his arrival )
There are no official records showing a connection between the three Keady family groups, but there are several clues that suggest a strong family link.
While official records found to date don’t help solve the mystery, a couple of Obituary notices for family members in the early 1900s shed some light on the relationship between Daniel and the two brothers, Thomas and Patrick.
First Connection – Obituary of Thomas Keady, Friday 19 July 1907
Thomas Keady of the Thomas and Patrick Nolan Family group died on Wednesday, 17 July 1907 at Wahring. Thomas was living on his farm at Wahring a rural area on the outskirts of Nagambie township in Victoria.
A transcript of the obituary published in The Nagambie Times of Friday 19 July 1907 is provided below. (Unfortunately the original scan available through Trove is extremely blurry and faded. It would not be legible if reproduced here)
Death — The death took place on Wednesday morning last of Mr Thomas Keady, the oldest resident of the Nagambie district. The exact age of the deceased is not known, but he was thought to be about 90 years. He was born in the county of Connaught, Ireland, and for a number of years after his arrival in Victoria resided in the Kilmore district, where he took an active part in the public life of the place and was a shire councillor. He then came to Wahring and entered upon farming and dairying pursuits, and had resided here for about 45 years. The deceased did not take any part in public affairs in this district, being of a very quiet and retiring disposition. He leaves behind him a widow, three sons—John, Michael, and P. J.—and a daughter, Mary; and P. N. Keady (of Wahring) and David Keady (of Murchison) are brothers. The funeral will leave the residence, at Wahring, to-day (Friday), at about 1 o’clock.
The key facts to be drawn from this article is reference to Thomas leaving behind two brothers, “P N Keady (i.e. Patrick Nolan Keady) and David Keady (of Murchison).
While this is useful information to confirm that Thomas and Patrick Nolan were indeed brothers, the second name “David” is confusing as there were no Keadys with the name “David” at this time in Victoria. However, it is probably reasonable to assume that there was a reporting or printing error and the name should have been “Daniel Keady”, not David Keady. Daniel Keady was living at Murchison at the time.
Assuming the naming error is correct then this confirms that Daniel was a brother of Thomas and Patrick Nolan Keady.
Second Connection – Obituary of Catherine Theresa Keady (1835-1928
The obituary notice for Catherine Theresa Keady(1835-1928) appeared in the Advocate, Melbourne, 7 June 1934.
Catherine was the fourth child and second daughter of Patrick Nolan Keady. Catherine died at the age of 70 on 13 May 1934 with the funeral and burial held on the next day, 14 May 1934 at Nagambie.

The coffin bearers were Thomas, Patrick, John and James Flynn, Catherine’s nephews, children of James Flynn and Catherine’s sister, Mary Elizabeth Keady (1856-1942). Another nephew is mentioned as a coffin bearer, Patrick Keady, probably the son of Michael Keady (1859-1929), Catherine’s brother.
The final coffin bearer is identified as “Daniel Keady (cousin)”. This “Daniel” could only possibly be one person, Daniel Augustus Keady (1873-1935), the son of Daniel Keady (1838-1928). (For the sake of completeness and for anyone who is aware of the other Daniel Keady living in Victoria at the time, he has been dismissed as the possible coffin bearer. That Daniel was part of John and Honora Keady family and lived about 300 kilometres away near Corryong. The chance of him being notified and travelling to Nagambie within a day of Catherine’s death would be impossible.)
As Daniel Augustus Keady was a cousin, this means his father, Daniel Keady (1838-1928) was a brother of Patrick Nolan Keady (1835-1913) and Thomas Keady (1829-1907).
In summary, these articles seem to prove quite clearly that Daniel Keady (1835-1928), Thomas Keady (1829-1907) and Patrick Nolan Keady (1935-19130 were brothers.





















































